Part 24: The Autism and the Autism


Hello, and welcome back to The Autistic Writer.

Let me give you an opinion. I believe that being autistic, the difference in how autistic people experience life and the world, is absolutely central to the autistic person’s identity. Autism cannot be separated from the autistic person.

There is a novel, titled The City and the City, written by China Miéville. The story is set in a fictional city called both Besźel and Ul Qoma. In this city, there are two separate populations who occupy the same space but do not engage with each other. From birth, these citizens are trained to “unsee” each other. They are aware of each other’s existence, but anyone who breaches the strict segregation is taken away by a kind of secret police.

You might be thinking, I know where this is going, Darren; you’re creating an analogy between this novel and the autistic and non-autistic populations in the real world. Well, no. Although there may be some mileage in that analogy, I’m thinking about something different but related.

There are conceptions of autism that risk driving apart the autism community and the autistic community, even though they share the same “space”. I don’t want to see a future in which autistic people who claim autism as their identity effectively inhabit a kind of Besźel, while others who have a different concept of autism luxuriate in an autistic Ul Qoma, and the two refuse to engage, either through fear or social coercion.

As a quick recap: The autistic community is made up of people who are autistic. The autism community is made up of anyone who has an interest in or relationship with autism, including autistic people. The overlap is, therefore, significant, much like the overlapping populations in the novel.

The various conceptual theories of autism throughout the history of the field have been at worst grossly wrong and harmful, such as refrigerator mother theory, or at best, incomplete in the sense that they don’t fully explain all aspects of autism, such as monotropism.

There is as yet no universally agreed theoretical model of autism that conclusively explains all aspects.

Diagnostic criteria are necessarily the product of the conceptual framework through which autism is understood. The way we clinically conceptualise autism determines which characteristics we identify as clinically fundamental to it, which characteristics we consider diagnostically significant, and ultimately who meets the criteria for a diagnosis.

The various clinically conceived theories and diagnostic models have stemmed from a medicalised view of autism; that autism is a disorder or condition which is described in terms of deficits.

As theories have been refined over the years, a consensus of what differences constitute autism in the medicalised view has emerged.

Three main strands of autism are usually considered: Differences in social and communication behaviours, differences in sensory processing, and restricted or repetitive behaviours (more broadly and fairly characterised as including highly focused interests and behaviours, and a preference for routine and predictability).

There is a movement in some parts of autism academia towards a concept of severe or profound autism.  The original Lancet Commission that proposed “profound autism” framed it as an administrative designation, rather than a formal diagnostic subtype. Its description included substantial intellectual disability or very limited language, alongside extensive care needs. It was never a proposal that intellectual disability should become a defining feature of all autism.

However, an opinion is emerging in some parts of autism academia, and in the general public (especially among parents of autistic children with very high support needs), that “profound autism” is the only “real” autism.   It is commonplace now for autistic people to be told they aren’t “really” autistic because they are not like the oft-cited “my autistic nephew” who can’t look after himself.

This “profound autism”-only approach, if widely adopted, could lead to an exclusion of autistic people without intellectual disability from support and services, and an intensifying social backlash from the so-called “warrior parents”.

A point of view put forward by professionals in favour of the severe/profound autism model is that people who have autism diagnoses under current criteria, but who do not have intellectual disability, should not be diagnosed as autistic, and that they are simply claiming an identity in which a diagnosis is unnecessary.  Psychologist Uta Frith, publicly cast doubt on the diagnosis of autistic TV personality Chris Packham.

Another psychologist, Naomi Fisher has been relentlessly posting across social media, arguing points that many autistic people feel misrepresent them, misrepresents autism, and is denigrating the neurodiversity movement.

Thankfully, other professionals in the autism field, notably Damian Milton and Monique Botha, are taking a public stand to disagree with these views that are threatening to obscure the very real difficulties faced by autistic people without intellectual disability.

It’s my opinion that conflating intellectual disability and autism helps no one.  Supporting an autistic person with intellectual disabilities will not become easier or more effective simply by saying they are severely or profoundly autistic: the intellectual disability needs to be transparently addressed, as does the autism.

By the same token, autistic people without intellectual disability who need support should not be neglected simply because their lack of intellectual disability means they are not considered severely or profoundly autistic.

Autistic people recognise in themselves and others autistic characteristics.  Even though all autistic people are different, or as I frame it, every autistic person has a different presentation of autism, as unique as a fingerprint, there is significant overlap in our characteristics and experiences.  This is part of why we claim being autistic as an identity.

Claiming autism as an identity does not mean the person doing so has no support needs; but those support needs will vary by the individual. 

Furthermore, the dynamic, shifting nature of autistic traits, along with changes in life circumstances, and ageing, mean the support needs of any autistic individual, including those with or without intellectual disability, will fluctuate.

We must accept that framing autism in a meaningful way requires acknowledging it as two distinct ideas at once: a diagnostic model and an identity.

A medicalised view of autism is necessary in order to framework diagnostics.  Formal diagnoses will continue to be necessary while access to support mechanisms and legal protections, either wholly or partially, depend on them, and while public opinion continues to see formally diagnosed autism as the only valid autism.

Support mechanisms must be pitched towards the support needs of individuals on an assessment basis, rather than trying to pigeon-hole complex individuals into arbitrary “levels” or “subtypes” of supposed severity.  These support mechanisms should be accessible in a way which recognises that the support needs of an autistic individual will fluctuate over time.

At the same time, as a society, we must accept that huge numbers of  autistic people do see being autistic as their core identity, and that an autistic community does exist. 

This identification as autistic need not be seen as in opposition to a diagnostic framework. And it definitely need not be seen as a barrier to support for autistic people who have greater support needs due either to co-occurring disabilities or simply their particular presentation of autistic traits.

An argument often deployed by those in favour of severity models of autism is that there is finite financial support for autistic people, and allocating some of that to those without co-occurring disabilities take resources away from those most in need.

Whether this is true or not, the answer is not to bar those with lower support needs from any support at all, but to increase the level of, and effective management of, financial resources overall, so that those in need can access support appropriate to their needs.

Let me be clear: I am not saying, “Throw money at it!” I am saying that resources need to appropriate for requirements, and they need to be managed effectively.

Using the claim that current resources do not match needs as an excuse to ignore the needs of some is clearly unfair and discriminatory.


That’s all for this time. Take care.


share this article:

The Autistic Writer is a labour of love, dedicated to promoting autism acceptance, understanding, and equality. If you’d like to help support this work, a small tip via Buy Me a Coffee would be greatly appreciated. Just click the button, below.



Banner displaying seven book covers by Darren R. Scothern, featuring dark fantasy, horror, science fiction, and thriller themes. Titles shown are Aberrations, Abominations, The Darkness Beyond the Veil, Blood Brothers, Isobel, Neuralchemy, and Wrap Time.


If you like this blog, I can also highly recommend the brilliant Mortgage Advisor on FIRE, which covers financial wellbeing, mental health, and autism issues, among much more.



Leave a Reply